Like many of you, I have spent much of the last several days
in stunned disbelief. Not because I didn’t suspect this might happen, but
rather because my yearning for a less hateful outcome was so strong, so
visceral that the news hit me as a personal failure.
I haven’t known where to turn or to whom I can safely bare
my soul. I’ve been snappy with folks who deserve better and suspicious of
casual comments. This morning – intentionally my first with WiFi access since
November 6th – I checked out the news and Facebook posts. My sense
of horror swelled and threatened to overwhelm as I read of minorities being harassed
and threatened. I had to stop reading the accounts of assault, invective,
spewing of ignorant hatred (yeah, I know, as if there’s any other kind).
My shock was gradually overtaken and replaced by the
realization that this wasn’t something that ‘happened’ on November 8th
or even within the scope of a single election cycle. One candidate did not
create the unreasoning hatred, selfishness and stupidity that has been
unleashed upon us. Or I should say, among
us.
The crowds of braying asses had to have been out there,
waiting. Held back by a more reasoned majority until just the right moment for
all the wrong people to step forward and lead them. The candidates did not create
the bigots and perverts who now tear hijabs from strangers’ heads and tell Hispanic
kids to ‘go home.’ They did not create the mob. They merely emboldened it.
The ones who write epithets on doors and then slink away
have been with us all the time, lurking in dark corners, needing only figureheads
to bring them out into the light of day. And along came Trump and Pence – and frankly,
Cruz and Ryan and McConnell and Conway and Giuliani, et al – to provide them
with a Nuremberg at which to rally. And rally they did.
But as much as I despise this President-elect and his
gay-hating, woman-diminishing batboy, I can’t place all the blame for this
catastrophe on the people who voted for them. I don’t understand it, and I will
never be able to fully trust anyone who is willing to admit this affiliation.
But neither can I whole-heartedly damn them. Because although it’s on them that
they voted for these wannabe despots, it’s on all of us that some of them
(please gawd, tell me it’s many of them) simply felt they had no other
direction to turn.
Those of us who care about equal rights, an even playing
field for minorities and immigrants and women, and just basic civility handed
this election to Trump just as much as the haters pushed him over the top.
This election exposes a failure of citizenship. Democrats
put forward a very deeply flawed candidate who proved unelectable even in the
face of a demonstrably evil opponent. We could have done better.
We should have
done better. We didn’t. We took the easy path of the known face and the
existing machinery. And we lost.
More than that, many of us who are old enough to know better
simply failed to engage. The non-voters, the sheer number of citizens content
with the label ‘bystander’ to this train wreck is the knife that cuts the
deepest.
So, I decided I would turn away from the news and the social
media firestorm but then I noticed something. And it gave me hope.
Look at who is most outraged, who is posting and responding
to posts. Look for those with tears in their eyes, tears of frustration and
rage and fear. And be glad and hopeful. They’re our children.
I thought back to the Sixties when I was a young white boy
in a lower-middle-class family comprising both emerging liberals and couldn’t-quite-overcome-their-upbringing
bigots. I thought of the incomprehensible newsreels of neatly dressed black
people pummeled by truncheons, pinned to walls by high pressure streams from
fire hoses, bitten by German Shepherds cheered on by grinning cops. I recall my dad, who was not what you would
call a liberal by today’s standards, being berated by one of the other ushers
at our church for suggesting that Mr. Harkins join their number. I recall with
great clarity the Harkins and Loving families of Lake Hills in the Sixties
although I could name relatively few of the other families. The Harkins and
Lovings stood out and came to reside in my long term memory because human
brains manage by exception. And those two families were exceptional – they were
the only ‘Negroes’ I knew before moving to California for high school.
Speaking of my dad, I recall him frantically waving down
another driver to prevent two little black girls from being run over and then
sobbing in relief as the oncoming car screeched to a halt just short of tragedy.
But I also recall him laughing along with racial stereotypes in jokes with his
friends. My dad was a product of his background but trying his damnedest to be
better. So when there was no time to think, when those little girls ran out
into the street or Mr. Harkins needed a lift to the hardware store, it didn’t
occur to him not to act. That’s the Dad I choose to recall as my mentor. The
other parts of him I forgave long ago just as I beg the forgiveness of my
children for my own darker corners.
In the Sixties, it was mainly young people who forced
change. And it was a tough fight. Not just for those like Goodman, Schwerner
and Chaney who gave their lives for the cause, but for those millions of young
people who made lesser stands in smaller venues but were nevertheless part of
the movement. Mike, who stood up in church to defend the preacher who spoke out
against VietNam was part of the movement. As was the young man who put flowers
in gun muzzles. And yes, the girl who brought home the non-white friend to meet
her parents and even – make that especially – the ones who in odd moments
simply frowned and said “That’s not funny” to the racist joke.
I remember watching the smoke from the burning of Watts from
the top tier at Dodger stadium. I was a twelve-year-old bystander in flood tide
pants but even then I wondered what would make people burn down their own
neighborhood. And I remembered. And I like to think I learned.
So, how do my memories of the Sixties relate to our current
national shaming? Directly, I would say.
We thought we’d won when the troops came home from Vietnam,
when the schools and city buses were integrated and a woman’s right to control
her own reproductive destiny was secured. We cheered the lions like Martin and Thurgood
and we thought, yes, we are moving forward. And we were.
But what we didn’t realize then was the difference between
progress and completion. And we left the work incomplete. We outlawed the worst
of the Klan’s activities but left much of the hatred intact to arise again
under other banners. We elected candidates who were good enough but failed to
find true leaders. And so we ended up with Hillary instead of Elizabeth.
We can do better, and we will do better. The reason I know
this is that my daughters are as disgusted with the failures of my generation
as was I with the failures of the Greatest Generation.
Progress has been made and so we have a better educated,
more worldly class of young people than we ourselves could claim to be. Witness:
while I can name and picture the one black kid in my high school in the 67-68
school year, my daughter’s minority friends are too numerous to recall
individually. And although I’m not sure I even had a minority friend over as a
kid (maybe Deborah Loving who I really liked but probably not because my buddy kind of had
a crush on her so that would have been weird in ways unrelated to race) I can’t
recall any grouping of my children’s school mates that was uniformly pale. In
my daughters’ generation, being non-white is unexceptional.
Thanks to the Internet, our kids’ generation is amazingly
connected and this gives them two distinct advantages: 1) they can share information
and organize actions in ways and at speeds we would have considered fictional because
in our day, it would have been; and, 2) the bigots, creepers, bullies and
bloviating a-holes just can’t keep their mouths shut (as always) but now that
means they self-identify on a wide stage.
My daughters and their friends are already studying, buckling
down, making plans, preparing to sally forth and that’s as it should be. This
is their fight. Not that we geezers won’t lend a hand. But the current disaster
is a product, at least in part, of our generation having been too
self-satisfied with the progress we made.
And as I said above, progress is not completion.
There can come a day, and I believe there will come a day, when the denizens of ‘white-is-right’
and similar camps will be forced back into the suppurating pustules from whence
they sprang. But it will take a lot of courage and hard work and even once they’re
defeated, we will need to post a watch. Because hatred arises from fear and
ignorance and those are two ills that seem to be DNA-embedded in the human
race.
We have to start now. Can’t wait for two years or four years
or someday. Have to start now.
I will wear my safety pin because while I can’t tell the
good guys from the bad on the basis of appearance, I can at least self-identify
as a safe harbor for those who might need it. And I will seek out opportunities
to be my better self - visibly, audibly so.
We have to start now. Because we can only do it while we’re
here.
“And I won't be laughing at the lies when I'm
gone
And I can't question how or when or why when I'm
gone
Can't live proud enough to die when I'm gone
So I guess I'll have to do it while I'm here”
Excerpted from
“When I'm Gone” by Phil Ochs